New Covenant
Parallel Gospel text: Greek (SBLGNT) · orthodox reading
La parabola dei vignaioli e la pietra scartata
Historical-halakhic study
Historical context
The parable is set in the final days of Jesus' activity in the Temple of Jerusalem, in open confrontation with the institutional leadership. The frame is that of an agrarian contract widespread in first-century Judea: sharecropping. An owner plants a vineyard (ampelôna, Hebrew kerem), leases it out (exédeto) to tenant farmers (geōrgoí), and departs. At harvest season he sends his servants to collect the agreed portion of the fruit. The economic scene is plausible and immediately recognizable to the audience: the keepers are not owners, but managers of another's fruit. In the background operates the great prophetic tradition of Israel: the vineyard is an ancient figure of the people of the covenant. The audience grasps the register at once. The conflict narrated does not set God against Israel, but the master against the unfaithful keepers: the priestly-scribal leadership that administers the house of God without rendering its fruit.
Lexical analysis
The term ampelôna (vineyard, Heb. kerem) is the figural key of the whole pericope. The contract is expressed by exédeto (leased out), a sharecropping agricultural lease, and the geōrgoí are the tenants, keepers and not owners. The sending of the servants uses apésteilen (sent with a mandate), the verb of shlichut, the formal mission of the agent: the doûlon (servant, Heb. ʽeved) is a figure of the prophets sent to collect the fruit of the covenant. The violence endured is described as atimásantes (dishonored), deprivation of the kavod owed to the master's envoy. The kýrios toû ampelônos (the lord of the vineyard) is a veiled figure of the owner of the vineyard; the hyión... agapētón (the beloved son) is the heir (klēronómos, Heb. nachalah). The expulsion éxō toû ampelônos (outside the vineyard) signals execution outside the enclosure. The audience's reaction, Mḕ génoito (May it never be!, Heb. chas we-chalilah), is a formula of aversion. It closes with the citation of the líthon... kephalḕn gōnías (the stone become the head of the corner, Heb. rosh pinnah) with the verb likmḗsei (it will crush).
Jewish sources
The metaphor rests entirely on the Scripture of Israel. The Song of the Vineyard of Isa 5:1-7 (shir ha-kerem) presents YHWH planting and hedging the vineyard-Israel: it is the direct parallel of the parable. Ps 80:9-17 describes the vineyard carried out of Egypt and tended by God as the vinedresser of his people, the immediate background of the image. The stone rejected by the builders and become rosh pinnah of Ps 118:22 belongs to the Passover Hallel sung in the Temple. The title of the beloved son recalls Gen 22:2, where Abraham leads to sacrifice the son, the beloved one (yahid). The background of likmḗsei points to Dan 2:44-45, the stone that pulverizes the kingdoms. The notice of execution outside the vineyard finds an echo in b.Sanhedrin 42b, on the place of execution outside the tribunal.
Halakhah and practical dimension
The parable moves within concrete juridical categories: the sharecropping contract, the obligation to render the agreed fruit, the honor owed to the agent. The figure of shlichut establishes that the envoy represents the one who sends him: to dishonor the servant is equivalent to dishonoring the master. On the practical level, the responsibility lies not with the entrusted inheritance but with the faithfulness of the administration. The vineyard demands the rendering of its fruit: stewardship is a mandate that obligates, not a possession that emancipates.
Non-supersessionist reading
The vineyard is not taken away from Israel. The transfer to others (v.16) concerns the keepers: the unfaithful tenants are removed and the management passes to new faithful keepers, not to a different people. The kerem remains intact; only the administration changes. The conflict is internal to Israel: the people (ho laós) stand on the side of Jesus and restrain the hand of the leaders, who fear him (v.19). Not Israel against Jesus, then, but the institutional leadership against the people and its Messiah. Those held responsible at v.19 are the grammateîs (the learned in the Torah, soferim) and the archiereîs (the chief priests, kohanim gedolim) of the Temple caste: a precise institutional leadership, not the Jews in general.
Textual notes
The title agapētós (beloved son) at v.13 is a narrative-typological element that recalls the aqedah of Gen 22:2, not yet a conciliar christological enunciation: its density is figural, internal to the narrative. The citation of Ps 118:22 at v.17 does not introduce a new text: the cornerstone is already on the lips of the people in the Temple, sung in the Hallel at Pesach; Jesus rereads what Israel sings. V.18, with likmḗsei, interweaves the motif of the stone of Ps 118 with that of the stone of Dan 2:44-45 that pulverizes the kingdoms.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the parable teach that God takes the election away from Israel?
Who are those responsible for the rejection according to v.19?
Why is the son called the beloved (agapētós)?
Is the cornerstone (v.17) a new image introduced by Jesus?
Biblical references
Cited in the commentary
Greek text: SBL Greek New Testament (SBLGNT), sblgnt.com. Copyright 2010 by the Society of Biblical Literature and Logos Bible Software. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (provided as-is, without warranties). Divided into pericopes by TeoCentro.