New Covenant
Parallel Gospel text: Greek (SBLGNT) · orthodox reading
Circoncisione e presentazione: Gesù dentro la Torah
Historical-halakhic study
Historical context
The passage of Lk 2:21-24 situates Jesus' first days entirely within first-century Jewish observance. On the eighth day the circumcision takes place (Lev 12:3), the sign of the berit milah that inscribes the child into the covenant of Abraham (Gen 17:10-14). This is not the inauguration of a new cult, but the full entry of a Jewish child into the lineage of the fathers: Jesus is received as bekhor, firstborn of Israel, according to the norms that governed every observant family.
The subsequent scene merges two distinct rites into a single pilgrimage to Jerusalem. The family goes up to the Temple both for the purification of the woman after childbirth (Lev 12:6-8) and for the presentation of the firstborn before YHWH, which takes up the redemption of the firstborn (pidyon ha-ben) codified in Ex 13:2,12-15 and Num 18:15-16. The offering chosen, two turtledoves or two pigeons rather than the lamb (Lev 12:8), openly signals the family's modest socioeconomic status: a detail that belies any idealization of a well-off Holy Family.
Lexical analysis
At v.21 the expression ehmerai okto (eight days) is the halakhic term for circumcision according to Lev 12:3; the infinitive tou peritemein auton (to circumcise him) recalls the verb of the berit milah, the sign of the covenant in the flesh. The name Iesous transliterates the Hebrew Yeshua (short form of Yehoshua), which means "YHWH saves": a theophoric name in which the saving subject is YHWH himself. The angel had imposed it before the conception (Lk 1:31), so that the imposition of the name belongs to the divine act of salvation, not to an autonomous religious choice of the parents.
At v.22 the plural genitive tou katharismou auton (the purification "of them") is attested by SBLGNT and NA28: the subject is plural, Mary and Joseph together, not the mother alone. The verb anegagon auton (they brought him up) expresses the ritual ascent to the Temple, with the subject still plural. Ton nomon Moyseos renders the Torah of Moses, where nomos translates torah as instruction and teaching, not "law" in a juridical-punitive sense. At v.23 gegraptai (it is written) is a perfect passive that indicates the permanent state of Scripture, and introduces Ex 13:2,12 with the formula pan arsen dianoigon metran (every male that opens the womb), that is, the bekhor. At v.24 thysian renders korban, the cultic offering that brings near, and zeugos trygonon e dyo nossous peristeron specifies the substitute offering of the poor.
Jewish sources
Lev 12:3 prescribes circumcision on the eighth day: the direct source of v.21. Lev 12:6-8 regulates the purification sacrifice of the woman after childbirth, with the lamb and a dove for those who can afford it, and the pair of turtledoves or two doves for the poor (v.8): the direct source of v.24. Ex 13:2 consecrates to YHWH every firstborn of humans and animals, and Num 18:15-16 establishes the redemption of the firstborn at the price of five shekels of silver: together they constitute the background of the presentation in v.23. The distinction between tohorah (the ritual purity of the woman after childbirth, seven plus thirty-three days for a male) and the pidyon ha-ben (redemption of the firstborn) belongs to the halakhic system that Luke presupposes as obvious for his readers.
Halakhah and practical dimension
The text describes a family that scrupulously fulfills the obligations of the Torah. Circumcision on the eighth day is a binding precept; the ascent to the Temple for the purification and for the presentation of the firstborn entails a journey and an offering. The choice of the two turtledoves, explicitly provided by Lev 12:8 for those who cannot offer the lamb, shows that the family observed the norm in its form conceived for the less affluent. Joseph's participation in the rite, suggested by the plural subject, reflects a practical dimension in which both parents accompany the act, even though the purification of Lev 12 is formally prescribed to the mother alone.
Non-supersessionist reading
Nothing in the passage opposes Jesus to the Torah or presents it as superseded. Luke carefully distinguishes the formulas: nomos Moyseos (v.22) recalls the norm transmitted through Moses, while nomos kyriou (vv.23-24) and gegraptai point to the permanent voice of Scripture. Far from marking a rupture, the observance described situates the child within the covenant and within the expectation of Israel. The family does not found a post-legal cult: it fulfills the Torah, and precisely in this fidelity is inscribed the salvific act announced by the name Yeshua.
Textual notes
At v.22 the reading auton ("of them", plural genitive) is the one adopted by SBLGNT and NA28, and includes Mary and Joseph in the purification. Some Western manuscripts present autes ("of her"), referring to the mother alone, a reading considered secondary and probably harmonizing with the prescription of Lev 12 that concerns only the woman after childbirth. The kyrios of vv.22-24 renders the Tetragrammaton YHWH according to the usage of the LXX: the presentation is made to YHWH, not to a generic priest.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is Jesus circumcised on the eighth day?
Who is purified in v.22, only Mary or both parents?
What does the offering of the two turtledoves indicate?
Is the presentation at the Temple the same thing as the purification?
Biblical references
Cited in the commentary
Greek text: SBL Greek New Testament (SBLGNT), sblgnt.com. Copyright 2010 by the Society of Biblical Literature and Logos Bible Software. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (provided as-is, without warranties). Divided into pericopes by TeoCentro.