New Covenant
Parallel Gospel text: Greek (SBLGNT) · orthodox reading
Il più grande comandamento
Historical-halakhic study
Historical context
Matthew 22:34-40 is set in Second Temple Jerusalem, probably in the last week before the Passover of 30 or 33 of the common era, within the public disputes in the Temple precinct between Jesus and the various groups of the Judaism of the time. The perushim (hoi Pharisaîoi), after the defeat of the tzedukim (Saddoukaíoi) on the question of the resurrection, gather to question Jesus on a central theme of the internal debate among the masters: the unifying principle of the 613 precepts of the Torah. The question about the «great commandment» is not an abstract theological trap, but reflects a real dispute documented in the Tannaitic literature, in which the masters distinguished between «light» (qallot) and «grave» (chamurot) mitzvot, seeking a klal — a general principle — capable of grounding the entire normative edifice. The nomikós who poses the question is a qualified expert in the written and oral Torah.
Lexical analysis
At v. 36, poía entolḕ megálē en tô nómōi («which great commandment in the Law») points to the debate on the degrees of importance of the mitzvot; the term nómos corresponds to the Hebrew Torah in a broad sense, including both the written norm and the oral tradition. At v. 37, Agapḗseis kýrion tòn theón sou is a direct quotation of the Shema (Deut 6:5): kýrios renders the Tetragrammaton, avoiding the pronunciation of the Name; kardía, psychḗ, diánoia mirror the Hebrew levav, nefesh, me'od — love with the whole being, in its interior, vital, and volitional dimensions. The future agapḗseis has imperative force, in line with the LXX usage for the commands of the Torah. At v. 39, Agapḗseis tòn plēsíon sou hōs seautón quotes Lev 19:18; plēsíon renders the Hebrew re'a, the neighbor of the covenant. Homoía autê («like it») indicates equal dignity, not hierarchical subordination. At v. 40, krématai («hangs upon») is a metaphor for the structural principle: the two commands are the hinge upon which the entire normative construction of the Torah and the Nevi'im hangs.
Jewish sources
The Shema (Deut 6:4-5) constitutes the central profession of faith of Second Temple Judaism: every Jew recited it morning and evening, as attested both by the Mishnah (m.Berakhot 1:1-2) and by the Qumran manuscripts (4QDeutn). The pairing of Deut 6:5 and Lev 19:18 as a synthesis of the Torah is not an innovation: Hillel, a generation before Jesus, had already formulated the equivalent principle — «What is hateful to you, do not do to your neighbor: this is the whole Torah, the rest is commentary; go and study» (b.Shabbat 31a). Rabbi Aqiva, later, will declare Lev 19:18 «the great principle (klal gadol) of the Torah», recognizing in the love of neighbor the hermeneutical foundation of the entire normative code. The Book of Jubilees and the Testament of the Twelve Patriarchs further attest, within intertestamental Judaism, the tendency to identify a unifying principle of the divine prescriptions. Jesus thus moves within a living and shared exegetical tradition, not against it.
Halakhah and practical dimension
The principle of the klal — the general precept that sums up and orients the application of the particular precepts — is a technical instrument of halakhic hermeneutics: a klal gadol does not replace the detailed mitzvot, but indicates their interpretive hierarchy and ultimate end (m.Sanhedrin 4:1 attests the method of reasoning by general principles in the normative procedure).
On the practical level, the love of neighbor (re'a, Lev 19:18) is articulated in concrete legal obligations: the prohibition of oppression (ona'ah, Lev 25:17), the restitution of what has been wrongfully taken, the protection of the stranger (ger), the relief of the poor (tzedaqah). The Shema, recited twice a day, constitutes a juridical-liturgical act of acceptance of the yoke of the Kingdom of Heaven (qabbalat 'ol malkhut shamayim), documented in m.Berakhot 2:2. The affirmation that «the whole Law and the Prophets hang upon them» (krématai) does not exempt one from the observance of the individual precepts: the klal orients and grounds, it does not abolish. The principle of the sheliaḥ — the envoy who acts in the name of the one who sends him («sheliaḥ adam kemoto», m.Berakhot 5:5; Qiddushin 43a) — is pertinent to the figure of the nomikós who questions: the doctor of the Law has a normative function delegated within the community.
Non-supersessionist reading
Jesus' response to the nomikós does not introduce a new Law in substitution of the Torah: it directly quotes the Shema and Lev 19:18, two foundational texts of Israel's normative corpus. The concluding formula — «on these two commandments depend the whole Law and the Prophets» — is an affirmation of fulfillment, not of abrogation: the verb krématai implies that the Torah remains intact, sustained and oriented by these two principles, not dissolved into them. Second Temple Judaism is not the pre-history of a revelation that supersedes it, but the living context in which this pericope has meaning. The perushim who question Jesus are masters of the oral Torah who share the method of the klal: the conversation takes place within Israel, not against it. No collective condemnation is present in the text; the distinction between archiereîs (the priestly oligarchy) and laos (the people) remains decisive for a correct historical reading.
Textual notes
- v. 34 — synḗchthēsan epì tò autó: «they gathered together» — the perushim assemble after Jesus had answered the tzedukim (ephímōsen toùs Saddoukaíous, «he had silenced the Sadducees»).
- v. 35 — nomikòs: «doctor of the Law», expert in the written and oral Torah; peirázōn: «putting him to the test», with the intent of public assessment; Didáskale: «Teacher», equivalent of rav.
- v. 36 — poía entolḕ megálē en tô nómōi: «great commandment in the Law» — reflects the rabbinic debate over which principle sums up the 613 precepts of the Torah.
- v. 37 — Agapḗseis kýrion tòn theón sou: quotation of the Shema (Deut 6:5); kýrios = the Tetragrammaton; kardía / psychḗ / diánoia = levav / nefesh / me'od, love with the whole being.
- v. 39 — Agapḗseis tòn plēsíon sou hōs seautón: quotation of Lev 19:18; plēsíon = re'a; homoía autê: equal dignity, not subordination (Hillel, b.Shabbat 31a; Aqiva: klal gadol).
- v. 40 — krématai: «hangs upon» — the two commands are the klal that sums up and grounds the Torah and the Nevi'im, it does not abolish them.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does Jesus cite two commandments instead of just one?
Does the term «like» (homoía) at v. 39 imply that the second commandment is inferior to the first?
Does the affirmation «the whole Law hangs upon them» mean that the 613 precepts are abolished?
Are the Pharisees who question Jesus adversaries or interlocutors?
Greek text: SBL Greek New Testament (SBLGNT), sblgnt.com. Copyright 2010 by the Society of Biblical Literature and Logos Bible Software. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (provided as-is, without warranties). Divided into pericopes by TeoCentro.