The ransom for many — Mt 20:17-28
Parallel Gospel text: Greek (SBLGNT) · orthodox reading
The ransom for many — Mt 20:17-28
Historical-halakhic study
Historical context
The pericope is set within the final journey to Yerushalayim, destination of the Passover pilgrimage, during the 1st cent. under the Roman prefecture of Judaea (6–41 CE). The third Passion prediction (vv.17-19) is the most detailed of the three and the only one to mention the handing over to the goyim (gentiles): a precise legal reality, since the Sanhedrin had lost the ius gladii — the right to carry out capital punishment — as attested by y.Sanhedrin 1:1; 7:2, which dates the loss to «forty years before the destruction of the Temple». Jn 18:31 («we are not permitted to put anyone to death») confirms the datum. The institutional actors are the kohanim (archiereîs), the Sadducean priestly class that administered the Sanctuary, and the soferim (grammateîs), learned interpreters of the Torah: together they constitute the Temple oligarchy, distinct from the laos (the people). The Qumranic model of the two messiahs — priestly and royal — provides a relevant cultural context for understanding the request of Salome, mother of the sons of Zavday.
Lexical analysis
The bar enash (Son of Man) of Dan 7:13 carries within himself both heavenly dignity and a destiny of suffering: his «handing over» is expressed by paradothḗsetai (yimmaser), passivum divinum of the verb moser, which signals the action of God underlying the historical event. Katakrinoûsin corresponds to the Hebrew yachayyevuhu mishpat mavet, the capital sentence of the Sanhedrin (cf. Mishnah Sanhedrin 7:1). The tò potḗrion (ha-kos) is the cup of divine wrath, a prophetic image rooted in Isa 51:17; Jer 25:15; Ps 75:9: «to drink the cup» designates the undergoing of eschatological judgment, not a psychological interior experience. Katakyrieúousin (v.25) indicates despotic dominion, an echo of the pagan moshlim. Diákonos (meshamesh, servant at table) and doûlos (eved, total slave) articulate the reversal of the hierarchy. Lýtron (kofer/pidyon) designates the price of liberation; antì pollōn (tachat rabbim) recalls the rabbim of the suffering Servant of Isa 53. The verbal aspect of paradothḗsetai (future passive indicative) underscores the certainty and sovereignty of the fulfillment.
Jewish sources
The request to sit at the right hand of the king (yeshivah bi-yemin) is grounded in Ps 109(110):1 («sit at my right hand»), a text widely used in Second Temple literature as the paradigm of the supreme messianic rank. 1Kgs 2:19 shows Bat-Sheva seated at the right hand of Shelomoh; Ps 44(45):10 attests the same royal iconography. The predestination of the places in the olam ha-ba is thematized in b.Bava Batra 75a, which transmits visions of the ranks reserved for the righteous in the world to come. The lýtron sinks its roots into the kofer of Ex 21:30 (ransom for the goring ox) and into the kofer nafsho of Ex 30:12 (the half-shekel as ransom of the census); Num 35:31 forbids the ransom for blood intentionally shed, thus delimiting the semantic field. The intertextual summit is Isa 53:10-12: the Servant offers nafsho asham (his life as a reparation sacrifice) la-rabbim (for the many). Hos 6:2 («after two days he will revive us, on the third day he will raise us up») is the scriptural echo of the «third day» (yom shelishi) at v.19.
Halakhah and practical dimension
V.28 constitutes the halakhic summit of the pericope: the category of pidyon nefesh (ransom of life) is a foundational legal principle in the biblical-rabbinic order, which governs the redemption of a person from death or servitude by means of a monetary or vital equivalent.
The concrete instruments attested are the following. First: the kofer (Ex 21:30; Num 35:31) — the substitutive price paid for the life of another, with precise halakhic limits: for premeditated homicide no kofer is admissible (Num 35:31), which renders the kofer of the Servant an act of extraordinary exceptionality. Second: the pidyon ha-ben — the ransom of the firstborn (Ex 13:13; Num 18:15-16) — an institution that presupposes the logic of life-for-life. Third: the category of the shaliach («sheliaḥ adam kemoto», m.Berakhot 5:5; Qiddushin 43a) — the envoy who acts with the full authority of the principal — intertwines with the figure of the bar enash sent to «serve and give his life». Fourth: the capital sentence of the Sanhedrin (mishpat mavet) presupposes the rules of m.Sanhedrin 7:1 and the procedure of m.Sanhedrin 4:1, which require qualified testimony and a qualified-majority vote. The diákonos/doûlos reversal is not an abstract ideal but a code of communal conduct: the meshamesh who serves at table inverts the hierarchy of the messianic beit ha-melekh.
Non-supersessionist reading
The Matthean christology of substitutive ransom neither annuls nor replaces Israel: the bar enash accomplishes the path of the Servant (Isa 42–53) from within the tradition of Israel, not against it. The talmidim are observant Jews gathered around a Jewish master; their dispute over the places of honor in the messianic kingdom is a discussion internal to Second Temple Judaism, not a break with it. The perushim (Pharisees) do not appear in this pericope: the institutional antagonists are the Sadducean kohanim (archiereîs) and the Temple oligarchy, not the people (laos) nor the renewal movements. The fulfillment of the prophecies of the Servant (Isa 53) does not invalidate the promise to Abraham: the logic of the pidyon is expansion, not substitution. Israel is not collectively condemned: the handing over to the goyim is an act of the leaders, not of the people. The teaching on service (vv.25-28) is proposed as a communal model within the malkhut, not as a condemnation of the Jewish institutions as such.
Textual notes
- v.17 — hoi dōdeka: the Twelve talmidim, disciples of the master; the journey to Yerushalayim is a Passover pilgrimage.
- v.18 — paradothḗsetai = yimmaser, passivum divinum of moser (to hand over); katakrinoûsin = yachayyevuhu mishpat mavet, capital sentence of the Sanhedrin (cf. Mishnah Sanhedrin 7:1).
- v.19 — toîs éthnesin = goyim; transfer to Roman jurisdiction because the Sanhedrin did not have the ius gladii (cf. Jn 18:31; y.Sanhedrin 1:1; 7:2); «on the third day he will rise»: echo of Hos 6:2.
- v.20 — hē mētēr tōn huiōn Zebedaíou: the mother of James and John, sons of Zavday; the request concerns the messianic malkhut.
- v.21 — Request for the places of honor in the messianic beit ha-melekh, the category of the yeshivah bi-yemin (cf. Ps 109[110]:1; 1Kgs 2:19).
- v.22 — tò potḗrion = ha-kos, the cup of divine wrath (Isa 51:17; Jer 25:15; Ps 75:9); «to drink the cup» = to undergo eschatological judgment.
- v.23 — Predestination of the rank in the olam ha-ba (cf. b.Bava Batra 75a); the places are reserved by the Father, not by the bar enash.
- v.25 — katakyrieúousin = despotic dominion, echo of the pagan moshlim; arkhontes tōn ethnōn = rulers of the nations, Roman imperial authorities.
- v.26 — diákonos = meshamesh (servant at table); reversal of rank in the community of the talmidim.
- v.27 — doûlos = eved; halakhic reversal of the hierarchy, echo of the eved Adonai (Isa 42–53).
- v.28 — lýtron antì pollōn = kofer/pidyon nefesh for the rabbim; halakhic category of ransom (Ex 21:30; 30:12; Num 35:31); the suffering Servant (Isa 53:10-12): nafsho asham, life given as asham (reparation sacrifice) la-rabbim.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does Ieshu announce that he will be handed over to the gentiles and not executed by the Sanhedrin?
What does «to drink the cup» mean in the Hebrew biblical tradition?
Does the term lýtron have roots in Jewish halakhah or is it a Greek concept?
Is the request to sit at the right and at the left a claim to power or a precise theological category?
Biblical references
Greek text: SBL Greek New Testament (SBLGNT), sblgnt.com. Copyright 2010 by the Society of Biblical Literature and Logos Bible Software. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (provided as-is, without warranties). Divided into pericopes by TeoCentro.