New Covenant
Parallel Gospel text: Greek (SBLGNT) · orthodox reading
L'indemoniato di Gerasa
Historical-halakhic study
Historical context
The «region of the Gerasenes» (Mk 5:1; Matthew reads «Gadarenes», some manuscripts «Gergesenes») belongs to the Decapolis, a league of ten cities east of the Jordan documented by Pliny the Elder (Naturalis Historia 5.74) and by Flavius Josephus (Bellum Judaicum 3.9.7): an area with a largely pagan population, where swine herding was ordinary practice, never Judean. Living «among the tombs» (mnēmeíōn = qevarim) entailed the tum'at met of Num 19:11-22: corpse impurity that excluded one from cultic and social life. The echo of the legio X Fretensis — stationed in Judea after 70 and bearing the boar standard — remains in the background as a resonance of the occupied territory, not as a systematic political code: the text itself glosses «we are many» (Mk 5:9). The healed man — a pagan — is finally sent to proclaim in the Decapolis: the first herald in gentile land, an anticipation of the covenantal opening of Isa 49:6.
Lexical analysis
The encounter opens with two abrupt narrative aorists: exelthóntos (punctiliar participle, completed action that opens the scene) and hypéntēsen (ingressive aorist, a sudden and perfective encounter). The pneuma akatharton is technical LXX vocabulary of cultic tum'ah (Lev 11), not generically «demon». The proskýnēsis (prosekýnēsen) is reverence extracted under duress, a forced confession under superior authority (cf. Jas 2:19), not a devotional act. The formula Tí emoì kaì soí (v. 7) renders the Hebrew mah li va-lakh מַה לִּי וָלָךְ, an OT formula of distancing (Judg 11:12; 2Sam 16:10; 1Kgs 17:18). The title hyiè toû theoû toû hypsístou corresponds to ben El 'Elyon אֵל עֶלְיוֹן, the Melchizedekian title of Gen 14:18-22, used in an inter-gentile context: an OT recognition under adjuration, not a christological confession in the Chalcedonian sense. The verb horkízō (v. 7) is a magico-juridical adjuration formula of the Second Temple period (cf. PGM IV.3007; Acts 19:13): an inverted exorcism. Tí ónomá soi (v. 9) echoes the mah-shemkha מַה שְּׁמֶךָ of Gen 32:28 and Judg 13:17: whoever knows the name holds juridical power over the entity. Legiṓn is a technical Latinism (Polybius VI.20: ca. 6000 infantry). The durative participle sōphronoûnta designates covenantal self-mastery — the restoration of kavod ha-beriot and of the tzelem Elohim of Gen 1:27 —, not a clinical psychological state. The imperative apángeilon (v. 19) is the heraldic summons of the ed עֵד (witness), distinct from the category of the apostolic shaliach, still foreign in this pre-paschal context.
Jewish sources
The man's stratified impurity — tombs (tum'at met, Num 19:16), pagan territory, pneuma akatharton — mirrors the levitically graduated logic of tum'ah (Lev 11-15). According to 1Enoch 15:8-11 the unclean spirits are the incorporeal nephilim who, lacking a physical body, seek a dwelling to inhabit: hence the territorial claim and the subsequent request for the swine. The cosmology of Deut 32:8 LXX («the boundaries of the nations entrusted to the angels») illuminates éxō tês chṓras (v. 10): the spirits claim the territory as assigned space. The cliff (katà toû krēmnoû) and the drowning of «about two thousand» swine (hōs dischílioi) resonate with Pharaoh's army sinking in the sea (Ex 14:27-28): a typological image of liberation, not an eschatological victory already fully realized. The formula mah li va-lakh recurs in 1Kgs 17:18 (the widow of Zarephath to Elijah) and 2Sam 16:10 (David to Abishai): a context of distancing in the face of divine power. Ho kýrios of v. 19 renders Adonai/YHWH of the saving action in Israel (cf. Isa 35:4-6): an OT reading of divine action. The opening to the nations actualizes the berakhah of Gen 12:3 and the program of Isa 49:6.
Halakhah and practical dimension
The pericope mobilizes a chain of juridical-ritual categories of the Second Temple period: every element of the narrative has a precise halakhic status that structures the man's exclusion and reintegration.
The man is impure through concurrent causes: tum'at met from contact with the tombs (Num 19:11-22; m.Ohalot 1:1: whoever remains under the same roof as a corpse contracts seven-day impurity), pagan territory (eretz ha-amim, presumably impure according to Pharisaic tradition; cf. m.Oholot 18:7), and the presence of the pneuma akatharton. The act of «cutting himself with stones» (katakóptōn heautòn líthois) overturns the Tannaitic prohibition of lo titgodedu לֹא תִתְגֹּדְדוּ (Deut 14:1; Lev 19:28): a pagan cultic practice of laceration, opposed to the holiness of the body prescribed by the Torah. The request for the «borders» (apò tôn horíōn autôn, v. 17) employs the Hellenistic civic formula of municipal removal on patrimonial grounds (loss of the herd), not theological. The command apángeilon (v. 19) does not establish a shaliach in the technical sense of «sheliaḥ adam kemoto» (m.Berakhot 5:5; Qiddushin 43a), since the apostolic category is post-paschal: the healed man is instead an ed, an eyewitness called to report what he has experienced. The restoration «clothed and in his right mind» (sōphronoûnta) signals the recovery of kavod ha-beriot, the dignity of the human person as an autonomous halakhic value (cf. b.Berakhot 19b on the honor of the creature).
Non-supersessionist reading
The pericope configures neither an abrogation of the clean/unclean distinction nor a replacement of Israel by the gentiles. The liberated man is not incorporated into a community alternative to the Torah: he is sent back to his oîkos, the beit av בֵּית אָב (v. 19), the nucleus of the gentile family network. The command to proclaim «what ho kýrios has done for you» remains within the OT grammar of the saving action of YHWH (Isa 35:4-6), without explicit christological superimposition in the text. The opening to the Decapolis actualizes the universal berakhah of Gen 12:3 («in you all the families of the earth will be blessed») and the program of Isa 49:6, according to which the covenantal benefit reaches the nations without thereby rescinding the covenant with Israel. The Perushim do not appear in the pericope: no anti-Pharisaic polemic is pertinent. The only negative actors are the unclean powers and, on the social plane, the owners of the herd who request the removal for patrimonial reasons. The salvation described is bodily, relational, and historical: «clothed and in his right mind», reintegrated into the family network, a witness in gentile land — a fulfillment that includes, it does not replace.
Textual notes
- v. 1 — tôn Gerasēnôn: SBLGNT reading of Mark; Matthew reads «Gadarenes», some manuscripts «Gergesenes»; Gerasa/Jerash, a city of the Decapolis. mnēmeíōn = qevarim קְבָרִים: tum'at met (Num 19:11-22). agélē choírōn = chazirim חֲזִירִים: unclean (Lev 11:7; Deut 14:8).
- v. 7 — Tí emoì kaì soí: rendering of mah li va-lakh מַה לִּי וָלָךְ (1Kgs 17:18; 2Sam 16:10; Judg 11:12). hyiè toû theoû toû hypsístou = ben El 'Elyon אֵל עֶלְיוֹן (Gen 14:18-22): inter-gentile Melchizedekian title. horkízō: magico-juridical adjuration (cf. PGM IV.3007; Acts 19:13).
- v. 9 — Tí ónomá soi: echo of mah-shemkha מַה שְּׁמֶךָ (Gen 32:28; Judg 13:17): a juridical act of control. Legiṓn: Latinism, ca. 6000 infantry (Polybius VI.20); the text itself glosses «we are many» (polloi esmen); resonance with the legio X Fretensis (boar standard) as an echo, not a political code.
- v. 15 — sōphronoûnta: durative participle of sōphrosýnē: covenantal self-mastery, restoration of the tzelem Elohim (Gen 1:27) and of kavod ha-beriot; not a psychological diagnosis.
- v. 10 — éxō tês chṓras: territorial claim of the spirits; cosmology of Deut 32:8 LXX on the boundaries of the nations assigned to the angels.
- vv. 19-20 — apángeilon: heraldic aorist imperative of the ed עֵד, not shaliach (m.Berakhot 5:5). ho kýrios: renders YHWH/Adonai of the saving action (Isa 35:4-6). Dekapólei: berakhah of Gen 12:3 and Isa 49:6 toward the nations.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does Jesus cross into pagan territory, and what does it mean to encounter the man among the tombs?
What does «Legion» mean, and does it really carry an anti-Roman political significance?
Does the healed man become a «shaliach» when he is sent to proclaim in the Decapolis?
Does the liberation of the man in the Decapolis imply that Israel is replaced by the gentiles?
Biblical references
Cited in the commentary
Greek text: SBL Greek New Testament (SBLGNT), sblgnt.com. Copyright 2010 by the Society of Biblical Literature and Logos Bible Software. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (provided as-is, without warranties). Divided into pericopes by TeoCentro.