Jeremiah 36 — Baruch's scroll (MT) vs. letter to the exiles (LXX)
The Bible as the first Jewish-Christian readers heard it
Parallel text: Masoretic Hebrew · Septuagint · orthodox reading
Jeremiah 36 — Baruch's scroll (MT) vs. letter to the exiles (LXX)
Historical-halakhic study
Significance. This passage recounts the birth of a prophetic book. In the fourth year of Yehoyaqìm (Jehoiakim), Yirmeyàhu dictates «from his mouth» (mi-pì) to the scribe Barùc son of Neriyàh all the words spoken since the days of Josiah, gathering them into a single «scroll-book» (megillàt-sèfer). The prophet is «restrained» (atzùr) and cannot access the Temple; he therefore sends Barùc to read the scroll aloud on the day of a public fast, before the assembled people. The reading takes place in the chamber of the scribe Ghemaryàh, at the entrance of the New Gate; Mikhàyhu hears it, goes down to report its contents to the court dignitaries gathered in the palace hall, and the officials summon Barùc to repeat the reading before them. The text is a foundational passage on the relationship between the prophet's oral word and the written word mediated by the scribe, and on the public efficacy of Scripture: the reading of the scroll sets in motion a confrontation between the prophetic voice and royal power, which will culminate — later in the chapter — in the king cutting and burning the scroll, compelling Yirmeyàhu to rewrite it.
Historical Reconstruction
The scene is set with precise chronology: «the fourth year of Yehoyaqìm» (v. 1, approximately 605 B.C., the year of the battle of Carchemish and the rise of Babylonian hegemony) for the dictation, and «the fifth year… ninth month» (v. 9, Kislev) for the public reading. These are the years in which Babylon becomes the dominant power and the prospect of exile becomes concrete. The scroll retrospectively collects the entire preceding preaching: it is a deliberate act of committing to writing, motivated by the prophet's inability to speak in person within the sacred precinct. The mention of the yom tzom, the proclaimed fast (vv. 6, 9), guarantees a large audience, swelled by people «who come from the cities of Yehudàh» to Jerusalem. The names of the officials (vv. 10, 12) belong to the scribal class connected to the house of Shaphan, a secretary already active under the Josianic reform: Ghemaryàh son of Shaphan makes his lishkàh (chamber) in the upper court available, and his son Mikhàyhu serves as intermediary with the court. This network of scribes sympathetic to Yirmeyàhu explains how the prophetic word was able to resound in the Temple and reach the palace despite the king's hostility. The «New Gate» (v. 10) was probably an access point to the Temple precinct recently renovated, a customary place for public assembly and proclamation.
Textual Notes (MT/LXX)
The divergence between the Masoretic Text (MT) and the Septuagint (LXX) here is, even before being lexical, structural. The book of Jeremiah circulates in two editions: the Greek is shorter by about one-seventh and arranges the material differently, in particular the oracles against the nations, placed at the middle of the book rather than at the end. As a result of this reordering, chapter numbering diverges widely between the two traditions, and what in the MT is the chapter of «Baruch's scroll» has no parallel in the LXX at the same position: the Greek column, at this point in its sequence, carries entirely different material (the discourse to the exiles on «seek the shalòm of the city» and the seventy years, which in the MT stand elsewhere). The reader must therefore understand that MT and LXX are not here mere word variants, but two different architectures of the same book. At the level of Hebrew vocabulary the following are noteworthy: megillàt-sèfer (v. 2), the «document roll», the material support of the extended prophetic text; mi-pì Yirmeyàhu (v. 4), «from the mouth of Jeremiah», emphasizing the oral-dictated origin of the writing; atzùr (v. 5), a participle indicating one who is «restrained/prevented», perhaps by an official ban from access to the Temple; the doublet af ve-chemàh (v. 7), «wrath and fury», accumulating two terms of anger for intensification; techinnàh (v. 7), the «supplication» that «falls» (i.e., is presented) before the Lord.
Jewish Reception (Rabbinic and Liturgical Tradition)
The rabbinic tradition makes this episode a reference point for the doctrine concerning the origin of the biblical books. In Bava Batra 15a, in the list of who «wrote» the books, it is stated that «Jeremiah wrote his own book, the book of Kings, and Lamentations», and the very scene of the scroll dictated to Barùc is adduced as the model of how a sacred text comes into being through dictation and scribal fixation (Jer 36:18 is cited there: «he dictated all these words to me orally, and I wrote them with ink in the book»). The figure of Barùc son of Neriyàh receives great honor: according to Megillah 16b, «as long as Baruch son of Neriah was alive in Babylon, Ezra, who was his disciple, did not leave him to go up» to Jerusalem — a tradition that makes Barùc the teacher of Ezra and thus links the transmission of the prophetic book to the chain of study. The liturgy likewise preserves the centrality of the public reading of the scroll as a foundational communal act, and the practice of the proclaimed tzom (vv. 6, 9) remains the paradigm of the assembly's penitential fast.
Aggadah
The aggadic reading concentrates attention on the contrast between the two «writings» of the chapter: the scroll of Barùc and the knife of the king. The prophet's word, as fragile as skin and ink, is cut and burned by the king, yet it is reborn: the prophet rewrites it «and there were added to them many words like them» (Jer 36:32), so that the attempt at suppression produces a more extensive text. Hence the reading according to which the divine word cannot be annihilated by power but in fact grows under persecution. The figure of Barùc is the subject of further reflection: a faithful scribe who places his talent at the service of another's voice, he embodies the humility of the transmitter — a theme to which the aggadah returns also in connection with his desire for «greatness» and the divine response that recalls him to the measure of the historical moment. The fast of the «ninth month» becomes, in homiletical reading, the missed opportunity: the people are gathered, the word is proclaimed, but — as the sequel will show — the king chooses fire over repentance.
New Testament Reception and Typology
The historical-literal Hebrew sense must first be established: the passage describes a concrete event in the reign of Yehoyaqìm — the composition of a prophetic scroll, its reading in the Temple on a day of fasting, the transmission of its contents to the court — and it announces the possibility of repentance («perhaps they will hear… so that each may turn from his evil way», vv. 3, 7). This meaning stands on its own, within the history of Israel, and is not to be read as a simple «prediction» of later events.
As subsequent reception, to be kept distinct from the original sense, the Christian tradition has read typologically the motif of the persecuted prophet and the word rejected by the powerful: the theme of the messenger spurned, the scroll burned, and the word that survives has been set beside the fate of prophetic preaching in the Gospels (for example the sequence of murdered prophets evoked in Mt 23:29–37) and the image of the «book» and the scroll in the apocalyptic literature of the New Testament (Rev 5; 10). This is a distinct typological level, a Christian interpretive echo, not the literal sense of the Hebrew text: the account of Yirmeyàhu and Barùc is not the hidden cipher of a New Testament reality, and its prophetic force does not depend on any subsequent fulfillment. Likewise, the devotion the passage calls for — «return» (teshuvàh) from the evil way — is not a «legalistic» religiosity to be superseded, but the very heart of the prophetic proclamation, which the subsequent tradition, both Jewish and Christian, has continued to understand as conversion of heart.
Practice and Liturgy
On the practical level this passage models the experience of the communal penitential fast and public reading of the word. Mishnah Taanit 2:1 describes the order of the communal fast: the ark is brought into the square, ashes are placed on the head of the community leader and of each person, and «the eldest addresses words of rebuke to the community», recalling that «it is not enough to fast and pray, but one must return and amend one's ways in deed» — precisely the movement that Barùc's scroll seeks to evoke when the techinnàh «falls before the Lord» so that each one «may turn from his evil way» (vv. 3, 7). The observance derived from this privileges effective conversion over the isolated ritual act: the fast has value as an instrument of teshuvàh, not as an end in itself. Normative too is the attention to the word read aloud before the assembly (be-oznè ha-ʿam, «in the hearing of the people», repeated in vv. 6, 10, 13–15), which makes the communal proclamation of Scripture the place where the prophetic word once again becomes living and challenging.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do the Hebrew and Greek columns of Jeremiah 36 say different things?
What does the letter to the exiles ask for?
What are the «seventy years» of v. 10?
Biblical references
Cited in the commentary
Greek text: Septuaginta, ed. A. Rahlfs (Stuttgart 1935), public domain.