Tobit 3 — The Two Prayers and the Mission of Raphael
The Bible as the first Jewish-Christian readers heard it
Parallel text: Masoretic Hebrew · Septuagint · orthodox reading
Tobit 3 — The Two Prayers and the Mission of Raphael
Historical-halakhic study
Tobit 3 interweaves two prayers of despair that rise on the same day from two distant places: that of Tobit, who has gone blind and is humiliated by his wife's reproaches, and that of Sara in Ecbatana of Media, who has lost seven husbands killed by the demon Asmodeus before the consummation of their marriages and is mocked by the servants of the household. Both, having reached the limit of their anguish, ask God for death. The narrative shows, however, that the two supplications are heard together: the angel Raphael — whose name means "El heals" — is sent to restore both of them, intertwining their two destinies in the future marriage of Tobias with Sara. The chapter is the theological hinge of the book: from prayerful despair to a providence that works through angelic mediation.
Historical Reconstruction
The scene is set in the eastern diaspora of the post-exilic period: Tobit is presented as a deportee from the tribe of Naphtali in Nineveh under the Assyrians, while Sara lives in Ecbatana, capital of Media. The book, though feigning an Assyrian setting of the seventh century B.C., reflects the conditions and concerns of Judaism in the diaspora of the Hellenistic period, dateable most likely between the third and second centuries B.C. The central themes — fidelity to the Law in a foreign land, endogamy within the kinship group, burial of the dead, almsgiving as an act of justice — mirror the identity anxieties of Jewish minority communities immersed in a pagan context. Tobit's prayer (vv. 3–5) reads the collective misfortune of exile not as an arbitrary fate but within the category of the covenant: the scattering among the nations is the consequence of "not heeding" the commandments, following the Deuteronomistic schema of blessing and curse. Sara, for her part, embodies the plight of a woman who, faithful and pure, is struck by undeserved misfortune and fears that she will drag down in grief the old age of her father, depriving him of his only heir.
Textual Notes
Tobit belongs to the deuterocanonical books: it is present in the Greek Septuagint and in the Christian canon of the Old Testament (Catholic and Orthodox), but is absent from the Hebrew Bible (Tanàk) and from the rabbinic canon. The "Hebrew" column therefore remains empty: this is a textual datum, not a lacuna. The text translated here is the Greek of the Septuagint, which for Tobit presents two main recensions: a shorter form (attested by the Codex Vaticanus and the Alexandrinus) and a longer, richer form, preserved chiefly by the Codex Sinaiticus. The Greek version is not the absolute original: the book's Semitic antiquity is confirmed by the finds at Qumran, where four Aramaic manuscripts and one Hebrew manuscript (4Q196–4Q200) came to light, attesting the circulation of the text in Semitic languages already in the second to first century B.C. Several Greek terms reveal a Semitic substratum: eleēmosýnai kaì alḗtheia (v. 2) calques the covenant binomial chèsed ve-emèt; eulogētòs eî (v. 11) reproduces the Hebrew liturgical formula barùkh attà; háidēs (v. 10) translates Sheòl. A recensional variant is noted at v. 16: the longer form attributes the greatness and glory to God ("before the glory of the great God"), while the shorter form translated here links the epithet "great" directly to Raphael.
Jewish Reception and Parallels
Although not canonized by the rabbis, Tobit shares motifs that resurface in the Jewish tradition. The figure of Asmodeus (Ashmedài) reappears in the Babylonian Talmud, where he is called "king of demons" and is the protagonist of the celebrated aggadic cycle connected to Solomon in tractate Gittin (b. Gittin 68a–b): a sign that the character circulated in the Jewish imagination well beyond the book of Tobit, within a shared post-exilic demonology. The very name Ashmedài is linked by scholars to the Iranian Aēšma-daēva, "demon of wrath," an indication of the contacts between Jewish angelology-demonology and the Persian world in the Second Temple period. The practice of almsgiving (tzedaqàh) as a meritorious act that "delivers from death" — the cornerstone of the entire book — also finds ample echo in the subsequent sapiential and rabbinic tradition. It should not, however, be asserted that the masters admitted Tobit into the canon: its authority remains external to the rabbinic corpus, and the parallels are to be understood as a shared narrative heritage, not as canonical reception.
Aggadah and Themes
The chapter constructs a narrative diptych of rare symmetry. The two prayers, uttered "on the same day" (v. 7), mirror each other: Tobit confesses the corporate sin of the people and asks to be "released" so as to become "earth," with an explicit echo of Genesis 3:19 (the return to dust); Sara, unjustly accused of being a husband-slaying widow, protests her innocence and implores that she not "defile" her father's name through suicide. The motif of Sheol/Hades runs through both voices: descent to the realm of the dead is feared at once as liberation and as reproach. On the symbolic level, Sara most plausibly resists the temptation of suicide precisely so as not to inflict further shame upon her father, choosing prayer instead of self-inflicted death. The demon Asmodeus is a narrative figure of the obstacle that prevents life and generation, not a cosmic dualistic principle: he is "bound" (dêsai, v. 17) by the angel and remains entirely subordinate to God's judgment. The chapter thus affirms, against every form of dualism, the absolute lordship of the Creator even over the powers of evil.
Patristic and New Testament Reception
Tobit was widely received and cited by the Church Fathers. Cyprian of Carthage, in his treatise De opere et eleemosynis, grounds much of his theology of almsgiving precisely in the book of Tobit, citing Tobit's exhortation to his son. Ambrose of Milan dedicated an entire work to the patriarch, De Tobia, reading his story through a moral and anti-usury lens. Augustine, in the De doctrina christiana, lists Tobit among the books of the canonical Scriptures received by the Church. The figure of Raphael, "one of the seven angels who stand before the glory of the Lord" (Tb 12:15), has nourished Christian angelology and is reflected, according to many commentators, in the "seven spirits" of the Apocalypse (Rev 1:4; 8:2). The theme of the prayer that rises "before the glory" of God and of the angel who presents the supplications of the righteous resonates in Rev 8:3–4, where an angel offers incense together with the prayers of the saints. The book's insistence that almsgiving is an act that "purifies from all sin" (Tb 12:9) is also close to the exhortation of 1 Pet 4:8 that charity "covers a multitude of sins."
Observance and Liturgy
In the Churches that recognize its canonicity, Tobit has held a stable place in catechesis and liturgy, in particular as a model of family piety, of charity toward the poor, and of marriage lived in the fear of God. The prayer of the spouses Tobias and Sara (Tb 8) has entered nuptial rites as a paradigm of conjugal union oriented not toward passion but toward holiness and progeny. Chapter 3, with its two supplications, is read as a school of prayer in tribulation: Tobit's corporate confession of sin teaches us to acknowledge the justice of God even in misfortune, while Sara's supplication displays the trust that perseveres in outraged innocence. The figure of Raphael, "medicine of God," is venerated as patron of the sick, of travelers, and of those betrothed. On the spiritual level, the book teaches that almsgiving (tzedaqàh), burial of the dead, and conjugal fidelity are the concrete works in which the faith of the diaspora becomes active justice, and that the prayer of the righteous does not fall into emptiness but is gathered before the divine glory.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is the Hebrew column of Tobit 3 empty?
Who is Asmodeus?
Why does Tobit confess the sins of the fathers?
Greek text: Septuaginta, ed. A. Rahlfs (Stuttgart 1935), public domain.