Job 2 — Ha-Satàn, the Trial in the Flesh, and the Silence of the Friends
The Bible as the first Jewish-Christian readers heard it
Parallel text: Masoretic Hebrew · Septuagint · orthodox reading
Job 2 — Ha-Satàn, the Trial in the Flesh, and the Silence of the Friends
Historical-halakhic study
Significance. Job 2:1-13 is the second scene of the prose prologue, the return of the heavenly council. For the second time the benè ha-Elohìm (the «sons of God», the members of the celestial court) present themselves before the throne, and with them ha-Satàn, «the Accuser» — with the article, a sign that this is a function and not a proper name. The trial intensifies: after the loss of possessions and children (ch. 1), now Job's very body is struck with an ulcer from the sole of his feet to the crown of his head. The thesis of the book is contained in Job's reply to his wife: «If we receive good from God, shall we not also receive evil?». The integrity (tummàh) of the righteous is not a contract with the deity, but a disinterested faithfulness; it is precisely what the Accuser had called into question with the key word ḥinnàm, «gratuitously». The pericope closes with the arrival of the three friends and the seven days of silence: the drama of the book will begin only when they start to speak (ch. 3).
Historical Reconstruction
The book of Job belongs to the wisdom literature of Israel and is situated, in its reflection on the suffering righteous one, within a horizon shared by the entire ancient Near East: Mesopotamian texts such as the Ludlul bēl nēmeqi («I will praise the lord of wisdom») and the so-called «Babylonian Job» already confront the paradox of the pious man struck down without fault. Job is placed outside Israel, in the land of Uz, and is a non-Israelite figure: tradition associates him with the patriarchal ancestors, and his friends come from regions renowned for wisdom, above all Teman in Edom. The prologue (chs. 1–2) and epilogue (42:7-17) are in prose and frame the great dialogic poem in verse (chs. 3–42:6). The «heavenly scene» with the Accuser does not describe a dualistic mythology, but a forensic procedure: ha-Satàn is the «prosecuting counsel» who, within the heavenly bet din, raises an objection concerning the sincerity of the righteous man. His action is always subordinate: he acts only «within your hand» and under the constraint «only spare his life». The same accusatory function recurs in Zechariah 3:1 (the Accuser at the right hand of the high priest Joshua) and in 1 Chronicles 21:1.
Textual Notes (MT / LXX)
The Masoretic text presents in this pericope the most discussed case of tiqqùn soferìm, the «corrections of the scribes». In v. 5 and v. 9 the verb used is barèkh, «bless», where the sense requires «curse»: tradition sees here a scribal euphemism, so as not to place the idea of cursing next to the name of God (the same phenomenon already in 1:5,11). The nèfesh of v. 6 is «life»/«the vital breath», not an immortal soul in the Greek sense. On the level of the Greek version, the LXX of Job is notoriously shorter than the MT (it lacks approximately one sixth, according to the testimony of Origen, who supplemented the lacunae from the recension of Theodotion, marking them with the asterisk). Yet precisely here the LXX amplifies: at v. 9 it introduces a long monologue by Job's wife (vv. 9a–9e in critical editions) — «How long will you hold out? […] your memory has vanished from the earth, sons and daughters, pangs of my womb whom I bore in vain; you sit among the worms in the open air, and I wander from house to house waiting for sunset. Speak a word against the Lord and die» — absent from the Hebrew text and belonging to the Alexandrian recension, clearly dramatic in intent. The LXX furthermore translates ha-Satàn with ho diábolos, «the devil/the slanderer»: it is this Greek lexical rendering, and not the Hebrew substrate, that subsequently furnished the term to later demonology. At v. 8 the Greek adds «outside the city» and reads kopría («dunghill») where the MT has afàr («ashes»).
Jewish Reception (Rabbinic and Liturgical)
In the Tannaitic and Amoraic tradition Job is the subject of lively discussion: the Mishnah mentions him in relation to the paradigmatic figure of the righteous man, and a celebrated baraita (b. Bava Batra 14b–15a) discusses authorship, dating and the status of the book, recording opinions ranging from Job as a contemporary of Moses to those who consider it a mashal, a «parable» whose hero «neither was nor existed». On the verse «skin for skin» (v. 4) the masters read Job's drama within the framework of the yissurìn, the «chastisements that refine», distinct from punishment for guilt; b. Berakhot 5a develops the doctrine of yissurìn shel ahavàh, «sufferings of love», examining precisely the suffering of the righteous. One rabbinic current emphasises Job's merits; another, stricter, reproaches him for the harshness of his contestations («Job spoke before the Holy One, blessed be He, words that a man should not say»). On the halakhic level, the episode of the three friends sitting in silence (v. 13) has become, in the traditional reading, the scriptural foundation of nichùm avelìm, the consolation of mourning: hence the norm that the visitor does not open his mouth until the bereaved speaks first.
Aggadah
The Aggadah greatly expands the figure. The Talmud numbers Job among the counsellors of Pharaoh at the time of Israel's oppression (b. Sotah 11a): while Jethro fled and was rewarded, and Balaam counselled evil, Job «was silent» — and was judged for that silence through his own sufferings. On the Accuser, the Aggadah (b. Bava Batra 16a) specifies that «ha-Satàn, the evil inclination (yetzer ha-raʿ), and the angel of death are one and the same»: that is, not an anti-God, but the principle of testing and accusing that is internal to the divine economy. Regarding Job's wife, the tradition discusses the matter with varied nuances: some see her as an instrument of the trial, others recognise her despair as a mother bereft of her children (a reading that the LXX, with its long lament, makes explicit). The number «seven» days and «seven» nights recalls the fullness of patriarchal mourning (cf. Gn 50:10, the seven days for Jacob).
New Testament Reception and Typology
The historical-literal Hebrew sense must be stated first: Job is the righteous man under trial who does not renounce his integrity, and the book is a sapiential challenge to the theology of mechanical retribution. This is the framework from which every subsequent reading is distinguished. In a later reception, the Christian tradition reread Job as a figure of the suffering righteous one: the Letter of James explicitly points to him as a model of hypomonè, of steadfastness — «you have heard of the patience of Job» (Jas 5:11) — perceiving the thread linking the perseverance of the righteous to the final compassion of God. The Patristic tradition would further develop a typological reading of Job struck down and immersed in pain in relation to the passion of the righteous one par excellence. Such readings are receptions, later and theologically oriented: they neither abolish nor «predict» the original Hebrew sense, which remains the open question of why the innocent suffer — left by the book without a doctrinal solution but resolved in the direct encounter with God (chs. 38–42).
Observance and Liturgy
On the practical and sapiential level, the pericope has shaped a concrete norm of conduct more than a rite. The rule of nichùm avelìm — derived from the seven days of silence of the three friends (v. 13) — prescribes that the one who visits the bereaved should not speak first, but wait for the mourner to open the conversation: authentic consolation is above all silent presence. From this also comes the institution of the shivʿàh, the «seven» days of strict mourning. On the sapiential-ethical level, Job's reply «we shall receive good and also evil» (v. 10) has become a paradigm of acceptance of providence in the devotional tradition: it connects to the blessing that the faithful pronounces even upon hearing a sorrowful piece of news («Blessed is the true Judge», Dayyàn ha-emèt, m. Berakhot 9:2,5, where one is taught to bless for evil as for good). Liturgically, finally, the book of Job is among the readings associated with days of mourning and, in certain communities, with the night of Tisha be-Av, in keeping with its tone of grief and questioning.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is ha-Satàn in Job 2 the Devil?
What does «skin for skin» mean (Job 2:4)?
Why does the wife say «bless God and die»?
Why do the friends remain in silence for seven days?
Biblical references
Greek text: Septuaginta, ed. A. Rahlfs (Stuttgart 1935), public domain.